Strongest on market presence: 30 homes for sale (agent website).
2Andrew Cowen Estate Agent Ltd1 Harcourt Place, Scarborough, YO11 2EPStrongest on market presence: 29 homes for sale (agent website), trading since 1999.
3CPH Property Services19 St Thomas St, Scarborough, YO11 1DYStrongest on market presence: 29 homes for sale (agent website), trading since 2015.
Full ranking
| # | Office | Register score | Measures | Reviews | Homes for sale | Since |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ellis HayStrongest on market presence: 30 homes for sale (agent website). | — | 30agent website | — | ||
| 2 | Andrew Cowen Estate Agent LtdStrongest on market presence: 29 homes for sale (agent website), trading since 1999. | — | 29agent website | 1999 | ||
| 3 | CPH Property ServicesStrongest on market presence: 29 homes for sale (agent website), trading since 2015. | — | 29agent website | 2015 | ||
| 4 | Colin Ellis Property ServicesStrongest on trust and longevity: 26 homes for sale (agent website), trading since 2020. | — | 26agent website | 2020 | ||
| 5 | GLS Properties LimitedStrongest on trust and longevity: 0 homes for sale (agent website), trading since 2013. | — | 0agent website | 2013 |
Measures, left to right: sales performance (40%), reviews (35%), market presence (15%), trust and longevity (10%). Bar height is the branch’s score on each; a faint bar means no data yet. Full method · This ranking as JSON
Head-to-head in Scarborough
- Andrew Cowen Estate Agent Ltd vs Ellis Hay
- CPH Property Services vs Ellis Hay
- Colin Ellis Property Services vs Ellis Hay
- Andrew Cowen Estate Agent Ltd vs CPH Property Services
- Andrew Cowen Estate Agent Ltd vs Colin Ellis Property Services
How this ranking works
Each measure is scored 0–100 against other Scarborough offices (presence) or a fixed scale (reviews, performance, trust). Missing measures are left out and the rest rescaled. Offices need at least 25% data coverage to be ranked in their town; below 75% the rank is marked provisional. Agents cannot pay to change their position.
The Scarborough market
Homes in Scarborough’s postcode districts (YO11, YO12) sold for a median £179,000 across 899 sales in the last 12 months (HM Land Registry). 24 estate and letting agent offices are on the register here.
All agents in North Yorkshire · Fastest in YO11 · Fastest in YO12
Nearby: Harrogate · Selby · Skipton · Ripon · North Yorkshire · Leyburn · Malton · Northallerton · Knaresborough · Richmond · Thirsk · Cross Hills
Not yet ranked
These Scarborough offices do not have enough data yet. They are added as reviews and listing data arrive.
Diane Millington · Harris Shields Collection · Hunters – Scarborough · Quayside Properties · Reeds Rains · Tipple Underwood · Tipple Underwood Estate Agents · Tower Estates
Questions and answers
Who is the best estate agent in Scarborough?
On the UK Agent Register score, Ellis Hay ranks first of 5 estate agent offices in Scarborough (October 2026). Strongest on market presence: 30 homes for sale (agent website).
How many estate agents are there in Scarborough?
24 estate and letting agent offices are on the register in Scarborough: 13 handle sales and 21 handle lettings.
Which Scarborough agent has the most homes for sale?
Ellis Hay, with 30 (agent website).
What do homes sell for in Scarborough?
A median £179,000 across 899 sales in its postcode districts (YO11, YO12) in the last 12 months (HM Land Registry).
How are agents ranked?
Four measures, weighted 40/35/15/10: sales performance, reviews, market presence and trust. Missing measures are left out and the rest rescaled; rankings below 75% data coverage are marked provisional. Full method at /methodology.
Sources: agents’ own websites (daily crawl), allAgents and ESTAS public review pages, historical market records, HM Land Registry Price Paid Data (OGL), Companies House, The Property Ombudsman and Property Redress Scheme registers.