Strongest on market presence: 29 homes for sale (agent website), trading since 2021.
2Reeds Rains Estate Agents16-18 Moorgate Street, Rotherham, S60 2DGStrongest on market presence: 5 homes for sale (register records Sep 2025), trading since 2023.
3William H Brown32 Mansfield Road, Rotherham, S60 2DRStrongest on market presence: 9 homes for sale (register records Aug 2025).
Full ranking
| # | Office | Register score | Measures | Reviews | Homes for sale | Since |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Carly Wilson EstatesStrongest on market presence: 29 homes for sale (agent website), trading since 2021. | — | 29agent website | 2021 | ||
| 2 | Reeds Rains Estate AgentsStrongest on market presence: 5 homes for sale (register records Sep 2025), trading since 2023. | — | 5register records Sep 2025 | 2023 | ||
| 3 | William H BrownStrongest on market presence: 9 homes for sale (register records Aug 2025). | — | 9register records Aug 2025 | — | ||
| 4 | Merryweathers est 1832Strongest on market presence: 4 homes for sale (register records Sep 2025), trading since 2008. | — | 4register records Sep 2025 | 2008 | ||
| 5 | BlundellsStrongest on market presence: 2 homes for sale (register records Sep 2025), trading since 1964. | — | 2register records Sep 2025 | 1964 | ||
| 6 | BartonsStrongest on trust and longevity: 1 homes for sale (register records Sep 2025), trading since 2000. | — | 1register records Sep 2025 | 2000 | ||
| 7 | Hunters Dearne ValleyStrongest on trust and longevity: 1 homes for sale (register records Sep 2025), trading since 2004. | — | 1register records Sep 2025 | 2004 | ||
| 8 | Martin & Co (Rotherham)Strongest on trust and longevity: 1 homes for sale (register records Feb 2025), trading since 2010. | — | 1register records Feb 2025 | 2010 | ||
| 9 | CrucibleStrongest on market presence: 2 homes for sale (register records Sep 2025). | — | 2register records Sep 2025 | — | ||
| 10 | Abode Lettings and Property Management LLPStrongest on trust and longevity: 0 homes for sale (agent website), trading since 2007. | — | 0agent website | 2007 | ||
| 11 | Eadon Lockwood & RiddleStrongest on market presence: 1 homes for sale (register records Sep 2025). | — | 1register records Sep 2025 | — |
Measures, left to right: sales performance (40%), reviews (35%), market presence (15%), trust and longevity (10%). Bar height is the branch’s score on each; a faint bar means no data yet. Full method · This ranking as JSON
Head-to-head in Rotherham
- Carly Wilson Estates vs Reeds Rains Estate Agents
- Carly Wilson Estates vs William H Brown
- Carly Wilson Estates vs Merryweathers est 1832
- Reeds Rains Estate Agents vs William H Brown
- Merryweathers est 1832 vs Reeds Rains Estate Agents
How this ranking works
Each measure is scored 0–100 against other Rotherham offices (presence) or a fixed scale (reviews, performance, trust). Missing measures are left out and the rest rescaled. Offices need at least 25% data coverage to be ranked in their town; below 75% the rank is marked provisional. Agents cannot pay to change their position.
The Rotherham market
Homes in Rotherham’s postcode districts (S66, S60, S65, S63, S62) sold for a median £190,000 across 1,852 sales in the last 12 months (HM Land Registry). 43 estate and letting agent offices are on the register here.
All agents in Rotherham · Fastest in S66 · Fastest in S60 · Fastest in S65 · Fastest in S63 · Fastest in S62
Not yet ranked
These Rotherham offices do not have enough data yet. They are added as reviews and listing data arrive.
Bramley Park Lettings · Caster Consultancy t/a Yopa · Elr (Wickersley) Ltd · Linda Stringer Individual Estate Agency, Powered by eXp · Merryweathers · Merryweathers Holdings Limited · PMM Residential Ltd t/a Yopa · Prewett Property Solutions Limited t/a Yopa · Rn Waterview Property Sales & Lettings Ltd t/a Ewemove · Sensis Property Management · Uflit · Uflit Gold Ltd · William H Brown · Yorkshire Accommodation Bureau Ltd
Questions and answers
Who is the best estate agent in Rotherham?
On the UK Agent Register score, Carly Wilson Estates ranks first of 11 estate agent offices in Rotherham (October 2026). Strongest on market presence: 29 homes for sale (agent website), trading since 2021.
How many estate agents are there in Rotherham?
43 estate and letting agent offices are on the register in Rotherham: 25 handle sales and 31 handle lettings.
Which Rotherham agent has the most homes for sale?
Carly Wilson Estates, with 29 (agent website).
What do homes sell for in Rotherham?
A median £190,000 across 1,852 sales in its postcode districts (S66, S60, S65, S63, S62) in the last 12 months (HM Land Registry).
How are agents ranked?
Four measures, weighted 40/35/15/10: sales performance, reviews, market presence and trust. Missing measures are left out and the rest rescaled; rankings below 75% data coverage are marked provisional. Full method at /methodology.
Sources: agents’ own websites (daily crawl), allAgents and ESTAS public review pages, historical market records, HM Land Registry Price Paid Data (OGL), Companies House, The Property Ombudsman and Property Redress Scheme registers.